The final keynote presentation at our recent Additive Manufacturing Strategies, held in Boston and co-hosted by SmarTech Analysis, was given by Craig Sungail, the Vice President of Global Research and Development for Global Advanced Metals, which just so happened to be one of the event sponsors. Sungail was part of our new 3D printing metals track, and presented a very interesting talk about tantalum, “the other gray metal.”
“We’ve used other metals for years, like cobalt chrome and stainless steel, to make implants,” Sungail said. “In 80% of the cases, for most people, it’s successful. But 20% of the time, patients aren’t happy with the results.”
He went on to say that there is a 10% revision rate each year for surgical implants 3D printed out of these other materials, for reasons such as infection, fracture, and becoming dislodged. That’s why he said that we should all “consider tantalum as an alternative.”
“This metal has a long history. We’ve been reviewing the literature for the past 25 years. The authors vary – physicians, universities, etc. But there is a broad, diverse group of people investigating this metal for medical devices.”
Sungail explained that these journals have determined that tantalum (Ta) is not toxic, which “can’t be said for some of the other metals out there today.” Additionally, the research shows that when using tantalum for implants, the osseointegration (bone ingrowth) of the implant into existing bone is pretty good, and perhaps even better than implants made with straight titanium or the Ti-64 alloy.
He pulled up a slide listing some of the other benefits of using tantalum to fabricate medical implants, including the fact that it could enhance local host defense mechanisms, and that it may even have some antibacterial properties.
Sungail offered a brief history about tantalum, which is a transition metal/element. He explained how the material got its name, bringing up a slide about Greek mythology, which I had not been expecting and was very interesting. Tantalus, the son of Zeus and a nymph, stole ambrosia and nectar from his father, and the punishment definitely fit the crime in this case – he was forced to stand in a pool of water that was tantalizingly close to a fruit tree.
“The water would fade away, and the fruit was just out of reach,” Sungail went on.
Then, in 1802, Swedish analytical chemist Anders Gustaf Ekeberg became the first person to discover tantalum when he successfully separated it from nyobium. Ekeberg was tantalized for a long time attempting to achieve what many others had not, and once he’d succeeded, he was given the honor of naming both of the new elements.
“I’m confident that every one of you has been touched by tantalum in some way,” Sungail said. “It’s highly conductive, with a high melting point, chemical and corrosion-resistant, dense, hard, ductile, and biocompatible. We have to use biocompatible carefully, but I’m using it with the FDA definition – it’s been implanted in some way into the body, and studies concluded that the implant was biocompatible.”
Sungail said that the most common application for tantalum is in the capacitor sector, such as when it’s used for cell phones. It does have a 40-year history in medical devices, and it can be mixed with materials in order to make super elements, which can be used in turbines for jet engines and energy generation.
He explained that the company is “truly global,” with locations in the US and Japan. GAM also has a controlling interest in the largest reserve of tantalum in the world, which is in Australia. I’m skipping ahead a little, but I thought this was a good question – at the end of the presentation, an attendee asked Sungail about the potential environmental impact of mining tantalum. He explained that GAM does what he referred to as a “bag and tag” when they receive ore from a conflict country.
“We ensure the money isn’t going to terrorists, we do it ethically. If it wasn’t mined ethically, we wouldn’t have sales,” he stated.
Back to where we were, Sungail said that two years ago, the company was taking a look at the various AM markets, wondering which would be the best to participate in with its tantalum. Just like the above graph shows, GAM determined that its “value proposition was best in medical, and not automotive.”
“We realized we’d have to bridge the chasm between early adopters and later innovators. We’d have to teach the industry about tantalum and that it can be printed,” he said.
So the company got to work, using 200W and 300W lasers to 3D print medical devices like spinal implants and baseplates out of its tantalum; these fully dense parts are now in testing.
Sungail listed several reasons why tantalum is a good material to use in 3D printed medical devices – it resists blood clotting, so it can be used to fabricate stents, and its high surface friction, proven through several research studies done on animals, is good for implant stabilization.
Tantalum also has no problem with corrosion, which has been reported as being an issue with other implant materials. Sungail had a slide that showed a picture of a non-tantalum 3D printed hip implant, which required revision post-surgery due to corrosion; researchers determined that it was caused due to crevice (the oxygen effect) and galvanic (dissimilar metals). He explained that debris due to friction can lead to even more issues with implants, such as inflammation in the tissue around the joint, which can cause severe pain, and that cobalt chrome and Ti-64 implants can even lead to toxic effects, like bone degradation, if absorbed into the body.
“Tantalum doesn’t corrode in a normal body,” Sungail said. “Its only attacker is hydrofloric acid, and threading should also not occur with tantalum.”
Looking at the graph above, you can see that the material’s printability comes down to several factors, of which bioinertness combines several; Sungail explained that “these are generic combinations of various features for easy reading.”
“It’s significantly more printable than some other metals we use for medical devices,” he continued. “Tensile and elongation properties unfortunately aren’t well reported, so we turned to engineering handbooks for this informnation, and modulus can be tuned with this material. There are four to five papers out now from researchers who printed tantalum and made it 70-80% porous, because this is the sweet spot for osseointegration. They noticed that the elastic modulus exactly matched bone in this range.”
“That’s the wrong question,” he said. “Ask the cost to the patient.”
While looking for a well-documented surgical study, GAM found an example with a 3D printed transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion (TLIF) implant, which is shown in the slide below with the cost benefit example analysis.
“We looked at the whole process, buying the raw material and printing and cleaning it and sterilizing it, packaging, surgery, to the point where the patient walks out,” Sungail explained. “Tantalum’s contribution to this implant on the slide is .02%. I think that’s nearly negligible. Tantalum will allow the patient to walk out much quicker and recover much quicker.”
3D printing isn’t even the most expensive part of the whole process – it’s the surgery itself. If annual implant surgery revisions can be prevented by even 5% from switching to tantalum, the medical industry will save $300-500 million a year.
Another example Sungail shared was a 3D printed knee implant made out of tantalum. The surgery took place in China back in 2017, and the patient was actually able to stand up two hours post-op…that’s a pretty impressive feat.
Wrapping things up, he pulled up a slide showing GAM’s “current” tantalum products for 3D printing. In its angular powder form, the material works for cold spray technology and DED printing, while spherical powder can be used with laser AM technologies. He said that the company is also working on tantalum tungsten, and is “always looking for partners,” especially since GAM doesn’t have its own 3D printing system yet and relies on its partnerships to print tantalum for them. However, Sungail said they are considering a 3D printer purchase…perhaps this is an announcement we’ll see in the near future?
Stay tuned to 3DPrint.com as we continue to bring you the news from AMS 2020.
Discuss this and other 3D printing topics at 3DPrintBoard.com or share your thoughts below.[Photos: Sarah Saunders]
Subscribe to Our Email Newsletter
Stay up-to-date on all the latest news from the 3D printing industry and receive information and offers from third party vendors.
You May Also Like
3D Printing News Unpeeled: Solenoids, Hydrogel Buildings and Missiles
Malgorzata A. Zboinska and others at Chalmers University of Technology and the Wallenberg Wood Science Center have managed to 3D print a hydrogel made of alginate and nano-cellulose. They hope...
3DXTECH Launches “Pellet to Part” Program for 3D Printing Materials
Always looking to shake up the material extrusion segment of 3D printing, Michigan-based 3DXTECH has introduced a novel initiative named the “Pellet to Part” program. To further drive collaboration with...
Interview: NAGASE Facilitates AM Adoption with EMPOWR3D 3D Printing Brand
The additive manufacturing (AM) market is entering a new phase in which large companies from outside of the segment have entered and begun consolidating. In reality, this trend has been...
Printing Money Episode 15: 3D Printing Markets & Deals, with AM Research and AMPOWER
Printing Money returns with Episode 15! This month, NewCap Partners‘ Danny Piper is joined by Scott Dunham, Executive Vice President of Research at Additive Manufacturing (AM) Research, and Matthias Schmidt-Lehr,...
Upload your 3D Models and get them printed quickly and efficiently.