Sometimes you make mistakes, I helped get Duann Scott a job at Shapeways and like some winding triangle constructed Banquo’s ghost he’s haunted all my tradeshows since. After stints at Shapeways and Autodesk, he’s now landed a plum job at something called nTopology, ntop for intimi. Unable to fly, fly, fly much longer I decided to meet with Duann at Formnext. Or actually I wanted to meet with someone called Blake who is like super nice and stuff; to everyone but me. Instead, in his absence, I was forced to bite the bullet and met with his surrogate, Duann.
Initially, I thought that ntop was kind of a 3D printed barber salon or some kind of fourth-wave coffee bar (without the ability to give one coffee). I think everyone asked to look at the finest mustaches, beards, and tattoos in 3D printing will correctly infer that nTopology is based in New York. What these hipster triangle rustlers are up to however may be a matter more difficult to discern. Nestled around the corner of the home of the croconut, and adjacent to Vespa Manhattan, nTopology wants to change the way things are designed and made.
The promise of nTopology is that they have found a way to combine simulation and design for complex parts in one fast application. ntop is kind of what would happen if Ansys, AutoCAD, and Grasshopper had some kind of CRISPR clone child that was raised on meth and Red Bull. nTopology lets you simulate, do Design of Experiments, lightweight, design for additive, reduce part count during the design phase of your project. Rather than serially using different programs requiring a part to be designed, then simulated, then redesigned, then maybe designed for additive, and then maybe ping pong back and forth a few times; this could all be taken into account of and done from the start in one application. What’s more, nTpopology will do this faster than other products so that calculation and wait times are reduced from days to hours or even minutes.
Duann says that, “what nTop does is enable geometries that other software can not.” “Existing CAD software uses b-reps or boundary representations to represent a geometry through NURBS, cones or faces. These legacy b-rep or mesh-based tools simply can not keep up with the latest geometry. New designs that can be produced through Additive Manufacturing require a complexity of parts that is too complex for many design software packages.” He cites the example of a “complex heat exchanger with many millions of polygons in an STL” and states that “just rotating this or making the slightest adjustment will cost a lot of time.”
“In one example such a heat exchanger could have 10,000 cells in a lattice structure this model would take 6 days to generate in b-rep software and two minutes in nTop.”
“In some cases with very complex files making a change can take hours or days, with us minutes. With nTop we can print it and slice it straight with the same tool” and “we completely bypass issues with the mesh.”
Duann mentioned that, “nTopology uses Signed Distance Functions where function gives a value for every point in a given 3D space, an SDF of a solid is negative when the corresponding point is inside the object and positive when it is outside.” Rather than dividing up the surface of a thing as good as possible in triangles and then mapping this entire patchwork nTop uses a mathematical function that returns the values that describe this area. When calculating changes, renders and operations traditional CAD runs through all the triangles, their locations and face normals before then calculating where what will be displayed or changed. nTop meanwhile solves the functions, speeding up the calculations considerably. Duann says that “due to these mathematical equations our geometries do not fail” and “since everything is an equation, it doesn’t matter how complex it is.”
With FEA and designed for 3D printed parts we often have lattice structures and very complex files and specifically for these cases nTop seems like it could make a difference. Duan believes that it gets even better if “you have 120 SKU and you would like to change or create new surface geometry for all of these parts. In the case of a spinal cage, for example, you may want to change all of the surface geometry in one go. With nTop you can apply the new cup geometry to all of the parts and essentially run it as a script.” He goes on to say, “what we’ve created with nTop is a programming language for geometries.” He thinks that, “this will be especially valuable in aerospace and medical” where their subscription software could “make a difference..where each time you make a change it could take days to draw that grid normally. This becomes especially relevant in these markets where we see users do lots of iterations.” Now with nTop “iteration is happening in a linear process” and we can “use the same recipe again and again to in seconds implement change.” What it also allows for is for “one advanced engineer to test and evaluate a design” who then “gives this toolkit to others who then conduct Design of Experiments.”
nTop seems like it may be a new design tool for a new more agile age of manufacturing. It faces an uphill struggle against the huge installed bases of the traditonal CAD packages but if in complex geometries the tool can outperform as advertised, then nTop’s 80 strong team will be getting reinforcements to bring the battle to the major players. For now, the team’s crusade against the hated STL file type is one that I can get behind.
You May Also Like
3D Printing and COVID-19, May 29, 2020 Update: Lessons for Going Forward
Companies, organizations and individuals continue to attempt to lend support to the COVID-19 pandemic supply effort. We will be providing regular updates about these initiatives where necessary in an attempt to ensure...
Virtual AM Medical Event: From Innovations to the Future of Additive Manufacturing in the Medical Industry
The American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) hosted a first-of-its-kind event with experts discussing the instrumental role and impact of additive manufacturing (AM) on patient care. Originally set to take...
3D Printing Review in Drug Delivery Systems: Pharmaceutical Particulates and Membranes
Researchers from Egypt, India, and the UK are studying the role of 3D printing in drug delivery systems. Their findings are detailed in the recently released ‘Pharmaceutical Particulates and Membranes...
3DHEALS2020: A Not So Lonely Planet
Only a few weeks away from 3DHEALS2020, and I just got off the phone with one of our speakers, Dr. Ho, from NAMIC Singapore. Our brief interview reminded me just...
View our broad assortment of in house and third party products.