Comparing FDM 3D Printed Parts with Carbon Nanotubes, Continuous Carbon Fiber and Short Carbon Fiber
Fused deposition modeling, or FDM, 3D printing has several advantages – thermoplastics can be used, which are easy to handle and are strong and durable enough to be used for producing both prototypes and practical parts. Additionally, FDM 3D printers use a simple mechanism to melt and extrude resin that doesn’t need expensive parts, like lasers, which makes the machines less expensive. But, the technology does not always provide enough strength for mechanical parts.
That’s why additional materials with good mechanical properties, such as carbon nanotubes (CNT) and fiber reinforced composites, are often added to improve strength; depending on the length, carbon fiber can also be divided up into both short and continuous fiber. A group of researchers from Doshisha University and Kyoraku Co., Ltd., both in Japan, recently published a study, titled “Comparison of strength of 3D printing objects using short fiber and continuous long fiber,” that compared the usefulness and strength of objects 3D printed with short carbon fiber, continuous carbon fiber, and multi-wall carbon nanotube (MWCNT).
The abstract reads, “In this research, composite materials were used to improve the strength of FDM 3D printed objects. The nanocomposites made from polylactic acid as matrix and multi-wall carbon nanotube as filler, short carbon fiber reinforced composite and continuous carbon fiber reinforced composite were prepared, and tensile test was carried out. As a result, the continuous fiber reinforced material exhibited tensile strength of about 7 times and elastic modulus about 5 times that of the other two materials. The strength was greatly improved by using the continuous fiber. The fracture surface after the test was observed using a scanning electron microscope. The result of observation shows that adhesion between the laminated layers and the relationship between the fiber and the matrix are bad, and improving these are necessary to increase strength. Comparing those materials, it is possible to improve the strength in some degree by using short fiber while maintaining ease of printing. On the other hand, by using continuous fiber it can be achieved significant strength improvement while printing was complicated.”
To make their PLA/MWCNT nanocomposite, the researchers used polylactic material as a matrix, with MWCNT as a filler, and formed the material into a 1.75 mm filament. They used commercial ONYX, carbon fiber, and NYLON materials from Markforged to 3D print tensile test pieces from continuous carbon fiber reinforced thermoplastic (continuous CFRTP) and short carbon fiber reinforced thermoplastic (short CFRTP).
“The specimen shape is different due to the limitation by the performance of the 3D printer,” the researchers wrote in the paper. “For PLA/MWCNT, smaller one was chosen to avoid warp and print quickly. The PLA/MWCNT has three outer walls and fills inside alternately at 45 degrees and -45 degrees.”
For the continuous CFRTP, carbon fibers oriented in the load direction were 3D printed in the center, while the outside was covered with either neat resin or short fiber reinforced composite; this last was used to 3D print the short CFRTP in the same manner as the PLA composite had been fabricate.
The researchers completed a tensile test on the pieces, and used a scanning electron microscope to observe images of the specimen’s fracture surface. They also looked at their stress and strain.
“In PLA/MWCNT, the stress increased almost linearly until fracture,” the paper explained. “The breaking strain was about 1 ~ 2%, and no stress reduction was occurred. Compared with neat PLA, the elastic modulus was not greatly improved but the tensile strength was improved and increased by 48% when 1wt% of MWCNT is added. In that case, the tensile strength was 53 MPa and the Young’s modulus was 3 GPa. Until 1 wt%, the tensile strength was improved as more CNT is added, but strength was decreased when 3wt% was added. It is because the aggregation of MWCNT. The aggregations are considered to act as internal defects of the material.”
When more MWCNT was added, the number of aggregates increased. The researchers found that the relationship between the fiber and the matrix, along with adhesion between the laminated layers, was not good – when these are improved, the strength will increase. Significant strength improvements can be achieved by using continuous fiber, but the 3D printing process is complicated, and it’s necessary to use modified equipment, such as a special nozzle. But short fiber is easier to print, and still offers some degree of improved strength.
“The short CFRTP and PLA/MWCNT are inferior in mechanical properties compared to the continuous. But they can be printed with conventional 3D printers without special modifying,” the researchers explained. “Especially the nanocomposites demonstrate its effect by adding a small amount. The mass concentration of fiber was 35.7 wt% for continuous CFRTP and 14.3 wt% for short CFRTP, but MWCNT was 3wt% or less. Generally, the smaller the amount of reinforcement, the more easy to print. In fact the PLA/MWCNT nanocomposite can be printed with commercially available 3D printer without special modified in this study. Continuous fiber and short fiber material should each have merits and demerits and should be used properly.”
Co-authors of the paper are T. Isobe, T. Tanaka, T. Nomura, and R. Yuasa.
Discuss this and other 3D printing topics at 3DPrintBoard.com or share your thoughts below.
You May Also Like
3D Printing Webinar and Virtual Event Roundup: April 10, 2021
We’ve got another packed week of webinars and virtual events for you, starting with Hannover Messe 2021 on Monday. What else is coming up this week: ASTM CoE’s personnel certificate...
3D Printing Webinar and Virtual Event Roundup: April 4, 2021
ASTM’s certificate course continues this week, and Cellink is discussing oncology drug screening applications in a webinar. Those are just two of the topics in this week’s webinar roundup, followed...
LimaCorporate and HSS Open First Hospital-Based Facility for 3D Printed Implants
In 2019, global orthopedics manufacturing company LimaCorporate S.p.A. and the Hospital for Special Surgery (HSS), the top-ranked orthopedic hospital in the United States, announced that they were partnering to establish the...
HP & Ford Team to Recycle 3D Printed Waste into Car Parts
In some of the most interesting additive manufacturing news I’ve heard recently, HP and Ford announced that they have teamed up to revolutionize how 3D printing waste is reused in...
View our broad assortment of in house and third party products.