As with any profession that has immediate, real life consequences that are starkly set out in terms of life and death, the more practice that a surgeon can get before actually performing a procedure, the better it is for everybody. The way in which surgeons historically would have gotten the hands on experience necessary to allow them to build their skills would have been by working with human cadavers, animals, and, finally, actual patients.
Clearly, the more practice, the better. Recent studies have demonstrated that there is a lapse in surgical skills that results when long periods of time intervene between opportunities to practice particular, highly advanced surgical techniques. Even for those who have years of surgical experience, there are incidences in which the time between opportunities to perform a particular procedure are long, or the particulars of a case are so strikingly unusual that practice is highly desirable.One such procedure that is, by its very nature, difficult is reconstructive cartilage grafting and often only the most experienced surgeons are given the chance to approach such an undertaking. Recently, however, at the University of Michigan Medical School, a medical resident was given the chance to do so. This wasn’t some shady, questionable moment in which more generosity than wisdom caused a decision to be made that risked a patient’s outcome. Instead, it was a procedure undertaken on a 3D printed model based on a real case that would allow the resident, Cher Zhao, to practice before she goes out to professionally practice medicine.
The ability of 3D printers to produce lifelike models for surgical preparation is being adopted by an increasing number of medical training programs. Documentation of ifs effectiveness as a learning tool is emerging from a multitude of sources, most recently in an article published in Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery by a team or researchers at University of Michigan. In an interview with Science Daily, lead author Dr. David Zopf of C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital explained the benefits that 3D printing is bringing to the preparation of the next generation of surgeons:
“3D printing is bringing a whole new meaning to hands-on experience for surgeons in training. Hands-on experience is critical for acquiring and improving surgical skills, especially of new and complex procedures. This is an exciting tool that not only offers trainees exposure to opportunities they otherwise wouldn’t have but that also allows them to demonstrate proficiency of skills before being performed on children.”
The particular procedure undertaken by Zhao, along with 18 of her fellow students, as part of her training was in an otolaryngology head and neck surgery dissection course and represented a case of severe tracheobronchomalacia, a condition in which the windpipe periodically collapses, thereby not allowing for the child to breathe normally. These kinds of interventions require the carving of cartilage from the patient’s ribs and grafting it into place, as Dr. Zopf described:
In addition to creating the model of the patient, Zhao was able to carve the mock cartilage from a material that very closely simulates the texture of human cartilage, giving her the advantage of making the entire procedure as lifelike as possible from start to finish, but without the consequences. It was a lesson that was not lost on Zhao, as evidenced by her response to the classroom exercise:
“Airway reconstruction for specialized cases is a technically demanding procedure that often involves carving cartilage to support and expand a reconstructed trachea. Currently, a surgeon in training has scarce opportunity to carve cartilage graft for this type of procedure. We want to see if 3D printing can accelerate and enhance surgical training.”
“You only get one chance to carve a harvested graft from a patient’s rib, so you have to do it perfectly the first time. It takes years of practice to learn the technical skills to do it. This was a very realistic experience and what’s great is you can keep printing dozens of these models at a time so you can practice over and over again.”
The use of 3D printed models gives not only new surgeons practice before performance, but helps experienced surgeons maintain those skills, especially when dealing with particularly rare types of procedures that may not occur with sufficient frequency for their regular practice. While it may seem intuitive that 3D printed models are a benefit to the training of medical students and the ongoing maintenance of skills for practitioners, very little is done on a broad scale in medicine without a significant amount of research done in support. As such, articles such as the one just published by the team at the University of Michigan are slowly, but surely, building the case for the integration of 3D printing into a wide variety of aspects of the practice of medicine. Discuss in the University of Michigan forum at 3DPB.com.