3D Printed Formwork for Topology Optimized Reinforced Concrete Walls


Share this Article

In the recently published ‘Topology Optimized Reinforced Concrete Walls Constructed with 3D Printed Formwork,’ authors Triveni Mudaliar, Rémy D. Lequesne, and Matthew Fadden (all of The University of Kansas Center for Research, Inc.) continue where others have left off in exploring 3D printing in the construction industry.

In this study, the authors are focused on two areas of technology: 3D printing and computational topology optimization (a mathematical technique for optimizing structural geometry). In using the two together, the significant benefits include the ability to build structures that are lighter in weight, aesthetically and architecturally pleasing, and reduced in volume. The team built two small-scale sample structures to test the idea for their concept, specifically in using 3D printed formwork for use with complex reinforced concrete (RC) structures.

Examples of topology optimized structures constructed in (a) Blanes, Spain, 2002 (not constructed) (Januszkiewicz and Banachowicz, 2017); (b) Takatsuki, Japan, 2004 (Donofrio, 2016); (c) Doha, Qatar, 2008 (Jewett, 2018); and (d) Lausanne, Switzerland, 2008 (Januszkiewicz and Banachowicz, 2017)

Noting that computational TO allows for more efficient and ‘appealing’ structures, the researchers realize that the technology has so far continued to offer challenges within industries outside automotive and aerospace, due to the following:

  • Challenges in building the irregular and non-linear designs that result from topology optimization
  • Difficulty in applying TO algorithms, generally using homogenous materials to reinforced concrete (RC) structures
  • Insufficient test data of topology optimized RC structures, resulting in limited knowledge of the behavior of optimized structures regarding stiffness, strength, and deformation

Rather than using other alternative techniques or avoiding use of formworks altogether, the authors suggest using a small 3D printer for creating formworks.

Topology optimized (a) UHPFRC slab with four supports (Jipa et al., 2016) and (b) PC beam testing under compression (Jewett and Carstensen, 2019)

“Several researchers have investigated different additive manufacturing techniques to efficiently build complex structures. These new emerging technologies may also speed up the process of construction. Currently, complex topology optimized structures could be directly built using either a D-shape process, contour crafting, or concrete printing,” stated the researchers.

Equipment for fabrication of formwork (a) Robotic CNC Milling, (b) Robotic Hot-Wire Cutting, (c) Robotic Abrasive Wire Cutting, (Sondergaard et al., 2018), (d) 3D Printer (Peters, 2014), (e) 25-Actuator Based Flexible Molds (Raun and Kirkegaard, 2014), (f) Flexible Fabric Formwork (Hawkins et al., 2016) and (g) Mesh Mold which uses uniform reinforcement of RC members as formwork and the concrete is placed inside the mesh (Hack et al., 2017)

During experimentation, the researchers built a control wall (CW) and an optimized wall (OW) as samples meant to show the potential for creating the formwork via 3D printing.

“Both specimens were constructed with base and top blocks. The base block simulated the foundation of a structural wall and was used to secure the wall to the strong floor of the structural laboratory,” stated the researchers. “A 55-kip hydraulic actuator was connected to the top block to apply lateral loads. The lateral force was applied at an elevation of 60 in. above the base block, resulting in an aspect ratio of 4 for both walls.

“The control specimen was designed so its lateral strength would be limited by flexure using concrete with a target compressive strength of 6,000 psi and Grade 36 reinforcement. Flexural reinforcement consisted of ten No. 2 bars in each of the boundary elements near the edges of the wall. Vertical web reinforcement consisting of two 12-gauge wires (diameter of 0.106 in.) at a 3 in. spacing also contributed slightly to the wall flexural strength.”

Reinforcement details of control wall specimen

The base and top blocks were cast with standard concrete, while the optimized wall was cast with high-strength concrete bearing a strength of 12000 psi. This mixture was meant to offer greater strength along with making up for the section loss—due to openings.

Reinforcing bars before (left) and after (right) the HCL treatment

PLA was used in the fabrication of the formwork for the optimized wall.

3D printed test specimens under three-point bending test. Specimen printed so the joint between layers was (a) in the vertical plane parallel to the longitudinal axis and (b) in the vertical plane perpendicular to the longitudinal axis

A 3D printer with 16×16 baseplate and total printing height of 21 inches was used for fabricating the optimized wall:

“A uniform formwork wall thickness of 0.125 in. was used throughout. The dimension was selected based on initial trials. The thickness was also selected such that the volume required to print one subpart of formwork was less than the volume of a spool of Polylactic Acid (PLA), the material used to print the formwork.”

Support structure/falsework and formwork for top block in control (left) and optimized walls (right)

One of the most serious constraints in the optimization of the RC structures was that the researchers found they could not use reinforcing bars for the sample used for optimization.

“These features of the algorithm were accommodated by using a rule of mixtures to define the stiffness and density of an effective composite material in the models used for analysis. However, this approach does not provide for a fully optimized composite system. It is reasonable to expect that an algorithm which somehow considers the presence of discrete reinforcement would produce a different optimized geometry,” concluded the researchers.

Principal strains at 6-kip lateral force in optimized sections designed to have strengths of at least 6 kips with volume ratios of (a) 0.51, (b) 0.65, (c) 0.74, (d) 0.84, and (e) 0.92 (element type C3D10, 0.5 in. mesh size)

“Future work could be aimed at producing optimized geometries for reinforced concrete structures subjected to loads beyond those required to cause concrete cracking or yielding of the reinforcement. A challenge for topology optimization of RC structures is not being able to include the use of discrete reinforcing bars in the model and having to use linear material properties. These features of the algorithm were accommodated by using a user defined composite material to define the rigidity and density of an equivalent material in the models used for analysis. However, this approach does not provide for a fully optimized composite system after cracking and yielding because reinforcement placement and the redistribution of stresses associated with cracking are not considered during the optimization process. It is reasonable to expect that an algorithm which somehow considers the presence of discrete reinforcement and concrete cracking would produce a different optimized geometry.”

3D printing in construction today continues to be a source of study and furthered development as researchers and builders around the world fabricate homes, offices, and concrete structures. What do you think of this news? Let us know your thoughts! Join the discussion of this and other 3D printing topics at 3DPrintBoard.com.

[Source / Images: ‘Topology Optimized Reinforced Concrete Walls Constructed with 3D Printed Formwork’]

Share this Article

Recent News

3D Printing News Briefs, May 21, 2022: Fictiv, Shellfish Reefs, and Oil & Gas

2022 Met Gala: 3D Gowns from Iris Van Herpen Steal the Spotlight


3D Design

3D Printed Art

3D Printed Food

3D Printed Guns

You May Also Like

Dior Showcases Past & Present of its Brand with Nearly 1,500 3D Printed Items

Fresh from the debut of its glamourous 3D printed concept store in Dubai, high-fashion brand Dior is showing off its rebranded flagship store on Avenue Montaigne in Paris after a...

3D Printed Shoe Soles Cut CO2 Emissions by 48%, Study Says

According to a study published in February 2022 titled “The First Environmental Evaluation of 3D-Printed Footwear,” the current standard production process involved in footwear manufacturing leads to “an industry where...


Kornit Digital Buys Tesoma, Expanding Digital Textile Production

Israeli firm Kornit Digital (NasdaqGS: KRNT) is fast becoming a leader in digital fashion, digital textiles and the on demand production and printing of garments. The firm has previously acquired...

Eco-Friendly 3D Printing: Sustainable Luxury Handbags Enabled with AM

When it comes to 3D printed fashion, I love it as much as I am skeptical of it. A lot of the 3D printed clothes I see, while gorgeous and...