In ‘Comparison of time and cost between conventional surgical planning and virtual surgical planning in orthognathic surgery in Korea,’ authors Si-Yeon Park, Dae-Seok Hwang, Jae-Min Song, and Uk-Kuy Kim explore the topics of 3D printing in the medical realm, but in regards to a very specific type of procedure. The study involved patients undergoing surgery of the jaw at the Pusan National University Dental Hospital from December 2017 to August 2018.
Intense planning is required for orthognathic surgery, with ‘accurate and delicate’ patient data analysis required. Traditional analysis is detailed and arduous, while virtual surgical planning (VSP) and 3D analysis involve:
- Analyzing skeletal deformities
- Performing virtual surgery
- Fabricating a surgical stent
Patients involved in the study had received Le Fort I osteotomy and bilateral sagittal split osteotomy (LFI+BSSO) or only bilateral sagittal split osteotomy (BSSO). Preoperative steps were taken at the hospital, with surgical planning performed through conventional and virtual methods. Patients were divided into two groups:
- Group One – patients who underwent LFI and BSSO regardless of genioplasty
- Group Two – patients who had undergone BSSO regardless of genioplasty
All patients underwent radiography. For Group One, the patients required maxillary and mandibular impression, with facebow transfer required for conventional analysis. For Group Two, the patients needed one pair of maxillary and mandibular impressions. The study included 47 patients, all of whom underwent surgery performed by one surgeon.
While conventional planning may often be responsible for errors, along with diminishing accuracy, virtual planning offers all the opposite benefits, preventing mistakes and improving precision and accuracy. Many surgeons are turning to VSP because of the many advantages outweighing more traditional techniques.
Along with being more accurate, VSP is also much faster; however, affordability—while theorized to offer a great advantage—did not factor in during this study. Virtual planning was found to be more expensive because the stent was outsourced for fabrication. The surgeon involved in the study still expects that VSP would be more cost-effective when all factors are considered—and especially in the amount of time saved.
“In this study, each step of VSP and CSP was not performed in the same place. Since it was performed separately, it is possible that its accuracy and cost-effectiveness decreased when it was processed in different laboratories,” concluded the researchers. “As a result, if the hospital is well equipped with software and hardware, each step of VSP and CSP can be performed in the same hospital and it will increase the cost-effectiveness and accuracy of the process by reducing errors and extra charges from the outsourced laboratory.
“With its high accuracy and time efficiency, VSP is the future for orthognathic surgery planning. As the VSP program continues to evolve, research on how to reduce the work time and cost for each step should be done.”
3D printing has made enormous impacts in the vast field of medicine, but especially the world of 3D models and surgical pre-planning. This spans so many different types of procedures meant to study, diagnose, and treat issues such as prostate cancer, knee replacement, and even prevention of heart-valve complications.
What do you think of this news? Let us know your thoughts! Join the discussion of this and other 3D printing topics at 3DPrintBoard.com.[Source / Image: ‘Comparison of time and cost between conventional surgical planning and virtual surgical planning in orthognathic surgery in Korea’]
You May Also Like
3D Printed Injection Molding and Anisotropy Targeted by Covestro
Upon acquiring the Functional Materials unit of Royal DSM, Covestro has been busy developing new 3D printing materials for a variety of applications. These range from TPU for insoles to...
3D Printing Innovator’s Roundtable Webinar: Ditching DfAM and Embracing Design Freedom
In an industry where change is constant and unpredictable, professionals across the manufacturing industry have turned to additive manufacturing (AM) to overcome design and supply chain challenges. But conventional AM...
3D Printing News Briefs, September 11, 2021: Rocket Nozzles, Ghost Guns, & More
In today’s 3D Printing News Briefs, Stratasys is the first founding partner of nFrontier’s Emerging Technologies Center in Berlin, which is looking to become one of Europe’s top facilities of...
3D Printing Webinar and Event Roundup: September 5, 2021
Buckle up, it’s a busy week of webinars and events ahead! From oxygen content in titanium grades and 3D printed orthotics and prosthetics to saving money in the GrabCAD Shop...
View our broad assortment of in house and third party products.