There’s so much more that goes into a 3D print than many people realize. To those unfamiliar with how the process works, it looks like simple magic – but there are a lot of factors that go into the process of turning a design into a physical 3D object, and a lot of decisions to be made. For example, what kind of infill should be used in a particular print? Infill percentage and pattern affect a lot more than just the weight and strength of a print, as studies have shown, and determining the optimal parameters can be tricky.
There are a lot of infill patterns one can choose from, including everything from standard honeycombs and triangles to cats and sharks, courtesy of MakerBot. One of the tricky aspects of infill optimization is trying to strike a good balance between strength and weight – it can be tough to design a strong, solid part without it ending up as heavy as a doorstop. But now a group of researchers from the Technical University of Denmark, Delft University of Technology, and the Technical University of Munich have developed a new type of infill that imparts durable strength without weighing an object down.
Like so many of the most effective human inventions, the researchers’ infill design was inspired by naturally occurring structures – in this case, bone.
“The so-called infill optimization automatically generates an porous infill structure for 3D printing,” Dr. Jun Wu, Assistant Professor of Advanced Manufacturing at TU Delft, told 3DPrint.com. “The numerically optimized structure is very similar to the trabecular bone, which is lightweight and mechanically strong. It gives valuable insight for linking engineering infill and nature infill.”
Trabecular bone, also known as cancellous or spongy bone, is less dense than cortical bone, the other type of bone tissue found in the human body. Composed of tiny lattice structures, trabecular bone is lightweight and flexible, making up the interior of bone structures, particularly near joints and in the ribs, skull and vertebrae. It may possess less strength than the exterior cortical bone, but it’s still plenty strong, especially for its light weight. Those are the properties that inspired the research team, and in a paper entitled “Infill Optimization for Additive Manufacturing — Approaching Bone-like Porous Structures,” they detail how they worked to translate those properties from nature to 3D printing.
According to the team, their methodology built on voxel-wise topology optimization.
“In particular, for the purpose of generating sparse yet stable structures distributed in the interior of a given shape, we propose upper bounds on the localized material volume in the proximity of each voxel in the design domain,” the paper states. “We then aggregate the local per-voxel constraints by their p-norm into an equivalent global constraint, in order to facilitate an efficient optimization process. Implemented on a high-resolution topology optimization framework, our results demonstrate mechanically optimized, detailed porous structures which mimic those found in nature.”
A complex mathematical algorithm was designed to generate an infill that resembled the porous structure of bone. The study details the multiple variables and sub-structures the researchers tested. In the end, the porous, trabecular bone-like structure was concluded to be highly promising for 3D printing – particularly large, lightweight parts. There’s still work to be done to further optimize the technique, but the printed structures held up well in testing for strength and robustness.
“We have presented a structural optimization method for obtaining stiffness optimized porous structures,” the paper concludes. “These numerically optimized structures visually resemble trabecular bone, which is lightweight and robust with respect to material deficiency and force variations. This makes the optimized interior structures an ideal candidate for application-specific infill in additive manufacturing.”
Dr. Wu is the first author of the paper; additional contributors include Niels Aage, Rüdiger Westermann, and Ole Sigmund. Discuss in the Bone Infill forum at 3DPB.com.
You May Also Like
3D Printing for the Segmental Scapula Prosthesis
In the recently published ‘Application of a three-dimensional printed segmental scapula prosthesis in the treatment of scapula tumors,’ authors Linglong Deng, Xing Zhao, Chi Wei, Wengiang Qu, Li Yu, and...
Happy Anniversary e-NABLE: Eight Years of Helping Others via 3D Printing
It’s hard to believe eight whole years have passed since e-NABLE and a long and varied list of 3D printed prosthetics were created; however, it is also difficult now to...
Interview with Elizabeth Rogers of Kuunda 3D and Daniel Martinez of Copper 3D on Copper 3D Antimicrobial 3D Printing
The 3D printing industry continues to experience more great gradual improvements. Special mention goes to the recent development...
Bionic Arm Advocate Tilly Lockey Speaks at the SingularityU South Africa Summit
Last week Tilly Lockey went on stage at the Kyalami Grand Prix circuit in Johannesburg, South Africa, during the SingularityU South African (SA) Summit, for a one-on-one with Benji Rosman,...
View our broad assortment of in house and third party products.