Stratasys Prevails in Inter Parte 3D Printing Related Patent Battle with Afinia

Inkbit

Share this Article

Scott Crump of Stratasys

Scott Crump of Stratasys

Stratasys and Afinia have been battling in the courts for years in a series of confrontations over various patents and claims, and now Stratasys says they’re happy with an announcement by the US Patent Trial and Appeal Board of the United States Patent & Trademark Office which denied a request from 3D printer manufacturer Afinia for what’s called an “inter partes review”of three FDM technology patents.

The patents relate to to liquefier structure, temperature control, and tool paths for constructing part perimeters in the 3D printing process.

usptoInter partes review is a trial proceeding conducted at the PTAB which considers the patentability of one or more claims in a patent. For “first-inventor-to-file patents,” the inter partes review process begins with a third party filing a petition nine months after the grant of a patent or issuance of a reissue patent, or if a post grant review is instituted.

The patent owner then files a preliminary response to the petition, and inter partes review, and the procedure for conducting inter partes review took effect during September of 2012, and it applies to any patent issued before September 16, 2012.

In denying Afinia’s requests, the PTAB said Afinia “has not demonstrated a reasonable likelihood of prevailing” in regard to their challenged claims against the Stratasys patents.

As it stands now, the PTAB say they only deny about one of every four inter partes review requests.

“We are very pleased with the U.S. Patent Trial and Appeal Board’s decision. These dismissals are evidence of the strength of our patent portfolio,” says Soonhee Jang, Vice President and Chief IP Counsel for Stratasys.

3dp_stratasys_logoThe same three patents are also set forth by Stratasys in a case called Stratasys, Inc. v. Microboards Technology, LLC dba Afinia. That case is currently pending in the United States District Court for the District of Minnesota. Stratasys says they’re continuing to pursue those claims in court, and they involve what the company says is an infringement by Afinia on three Stratasys patents.

The co-founder and chief innovation officer of Stratasys, Scott Crump, is the inventor of Fused Deposition Modeling technology.

Stratasys has patented FDM and PolyJet 3D Printing technologies, and those processes are used to produce prototypes and manufactured goods directly from 3D files or other 3D content.

Stratasys subsidiaries include MakerBot and Solidscape, and they also offer a digital parts manufacturing service, Stratasys Direct Manufacturing.

Stratasys currently holds more than 800 granted or pending patents related to additive manufacturing methods and processes.

fdm-patentWhat impact do you think this decision from the Patent Trial and Appeal Board of the United States Patent & Trademark Office will have on the 3D printing business in general? Let us know in the Stratasys vs. Afinia forum thread on 3DPB.com.

 

Share this Article


Recent News

3D Printing News Briefs, May 28, 2022: Metal 3D Printer, Machine Learning, & More

Digital Supply Chains and 3D Printing Come to Alaska via Ivaldi



Categories

3D Design

3D Printed Art

3D Printed Food

3D Printed Guns


You May Also Like

3D Printing News Briefs, May 26, 2022: Filaments & Ink, Cultural Artifacts, & More

In 3D Printing News Briefs today, we’ll be sharing some material news, followed by a new 3D printing-focused product line, and finally onto cultural heritage. First, Braskem has released three...

New 3D Printing Hardware, Collaborations & More at RAPID+TCT 2022

This year, the RAPID + TCT conference kicked off Tuesday with new products, materials, and solutions, many of them on display at the event. 2022 is the 31st year for...

Featured

Shell 3D Prints Impellers for Its Dutch Refinery

The oil and gas industry hasn’t adopted additive manufacturing (AM) techniques to the same extent as some other large-scale industries, like the aerospace and automotive sectors. Nonetheless, oil and gas...

Featured

The Digital Textile Tech Behind Kornit’s Sustainable Fashion

I recently traveled to Israel to attend Kornit Fashion Week Tel Aviv 2022 and see Kornit Digital (NASDAQ: KRNT) introduce its Atlas MAX Poly and Apollo solutions for digital, sustainable fashion. The...