US researchers are looking for ways to improve the diagnosis of breast cancer and the use of phantoms, outlining their findings in the recently published ‘Imaging properties of 3D printed breast phantoms for lesion localization and core needle biopsy training.’
A core needle biopsy (CNB) often accompanies the process of diagnosing breast cancer, due to excellent accuracy; however, like any other technology, training is required for radiologists. The use of phantoms in training continues to be successful, allowing for hands-on education regarding procedures that involve imaging probes and procedural instruments. Affordability is a limiting factor though, with commercial biopsy phantoms typically priced from $350 to $450. Because of this, many training programs use alternative materials like food, imitating soft tissue.
In the development of 3D printed breast phantoms for this study, the researchers realized the ideal product would offer the following features:
- Anatomical accuracy
- Adequate visualization of target lesions
- Tissue integrity
- Potential for several uses
- Easy maintenance
“In the context of breast imaging, several papers have explored the benefit of 3D printed phantoms for image quality analysis, surgical planning, and implantable bioprinted breast scaffolds,” stated the authors. “Researchers have also created phantoms from 3D printed molds filled with ultrasound compatible polymers. However, to our knowledge, no 3D printed phantoms which accurately mimic breast tissue characteristics, are feasible for multimodality imaging, and are produced at a low cost, exist.”
Three samples were created, customized for both training in performing biopsies as well as imaging evaluation. Traditional phantoms were also fabricated, using chicken breasts, gelatin, and olives and blueberries to mimic tumors.
Each phantom was assessed by a trained breast radiologist. They were also tested in biopsy training seminars (consisting of at least four trainees each time), rated on a scale of one to five.
Evaluations showed that the 3D printed breast phantoms were more accurate than the traditional models, with the TissueMatrix material demonstrating the best tactile simulation of tissue. The researchers did note, however, that there was a ‘pronounced limitation’ due to the lack of US beam penetration.
The chicken breast phantom showed the best results in terms of US beam penetration, image quality, and material hardness. The phantom made from gelatin displayed ‘acceptable beam penetration and image quality,’ but inferior tactile stimulation quality.
“Gelatin is particularly fragile and the density too soft compared to human breast tissue. Small cracks created in the gelatin during routine handling, multiple biopsies, or excessive pressure from the probe can create pockets of air within the model and obstruct visualization of targets,” added the researchers in conclusion. “The short shelf life of the gelatin and creation of air tracks with each biopsy limits reusability. Preservatives may be added to extend shelf life; however, the single use nature of gelatin models makes preservatives unnecessary.
“Limitations of this study include the lack of additional types of printing technologies or materials, including flexible materials printed with the use of material extrusion, vat photopolymerization, and other types of material jetting printers (i.e. 3D Systems and Mimaki).”
What do you think of this news? Let us know your thoughts! Join the discussion of this and other 3D printing topics at 3DPrintBoard.com.[Source / Images: ‘Imaging properties of 3D printed breast phantoms for lesion localization and core needle biopsy training’]
You May Also Like
3D Printed Injection Molding and Anisotropy Targeted by Covestro
Upon acquiring the Functional Materials unit of Royal DSM, Covestro has been busy developing new 3D printing materials for a variety of applications. These range from TPU for insoles to...
3D Printing Innovator’s Roundtable Webinar: Ditching DfAM and Embracing Design Freedom
In an industry where change is constant and unpredictable, professionals across the manufacturing industry have turned to additive manufacturing (AM) to overcome design and supply chain challenges. But conventional AM...
3D Printing News Briefs, September 11, 2021: Rocket Nozzles, Ghost Guns, & More
In today’s 3D Printing News Briefs, Stratasys is the first founding partner of nFrontier’s Emerging Technologies Center in Berlin, which is looking to become one of Europe’s top facilities of...
3D Printing Webinar and Event Roundup: September 5, 2021
Buckle up, it’s a busy week of webinars and events ahead! From oxygen content in titanium grades and 3D printed orthotics and prosthetics to saving money in the GrabCAD Shop...
View our broad assortment of in house and third party products.