Additive Manufacturing Strategies

CNC Supporter Declares End of 3D Printing Revolution Came with a Whimper and No Bang

ST Medical Devices

Share this Article

Screen Shot 2015-12-23 at 10.14.03 AMIn a provocatively named article, author James Brumley suggested that “3D Printing Came and Went, While CNC Simply Got Better.” He goes on to say that 3D Systems and Stratasys were no more than flashes in the pan, novelty driven companies that got their 15 minutes of fame, but whose presence is already turning sour. His argument is that instead of those companies, we all should really be paying attention to companies such as Bulova Technologies Group which is introducing the latest and greatest in CNC technology:

“3D printing has most definitely not displaced CNC (computer numerical control) equipment as the most effective means of turning a hunk of metal into something useful by cutting it into a specific shape. Indeed, if anything, the advent of 3D printing has underscored just how impressive current CNC machines are.”

CNC-Waterjet-Machine-CNC-Waterjet-CutterFor obvious reasons, this caught the attention of the editors here at 3DPrint.com, because we’re not necessarily in complete agreement with his analysis…otherwise, we’d be named something like AwesomeCNC.com. This is not to suggest that he is hyping a worthless technology — quite the opposite in fact — but rather that the more likely explanation is that it’s not an either/or situation. The embrace of the magic of CNC doesn’t mean that we have to wholesale reject the possibilities presented by 3D printing, throwing out the proverbial baby with the bath water.

jb-waist-smallIf you read beyond the headline, and we certainly can’t fault him for having come up with a catchy headline, Brumley does acknowledge that really he is talking about a specific area in 3D printing. After all, nobody is arguing that we should be milling replacement organs or that the CNC will be the machine of choice in the future for making customizable dolls like the Makies. In his piece, he elaborated on his idea about CNC machines as set apart from 3D printers:

“[T]here are 3D printers that can cut most types of metal, starting with a solid block and then stripping away the material that isn’t part of the intended shape. Here’s a little detail about metal-forming 3D printers though…most of them are actually CNC machines that are called something else. They’re also priced like their CNC brethren, ergo offering no cost or functionality advantage.”

Herein lies the heart of his invective against 3D printers: some of them aren’t actually 3D printers but rather CNC machines. It seems a bit rash to announce, therefore, the end of 3D printing as a result of the failure of machines that aren’t 3D printers to supersede the machines types that they actually already are. Perhaps drama has gotten the better part of clarity here.

In other words, in my humble opinion – probably shared by many members of the 3D printing community – the rumors of the death of 3D printing are greatly exaggerated.  Do you agree with Brumley?  Let us know in the CNC Vs. 3D Printing forum on 3DPB.com.

 

Share this Article


Recent News

NASA Highlights Space 3D Printing Commercialization

Metal 3D Printing Quality Control Systems Developed by Materialise and Sigma Labs



Categories

3D Design

3D Printed Art

3D Printed Food

3D Printed Guns


You May Also Like

3DPOD Episode 93: Bound Metal 3D Printing with Mantle CEO Ted Sorom

Ted Sorom, CEO and co-founder of Mantle, is looking to revolutionize metal 3D printing. Mantle has a paste extrusion method that features a post-machining step to mill unfinished parts and...

Featured

Big and Tall Metal 3D Printer Heralds Rocket Future for China’s EPlus 3D

Until recently, Chinese 3D printer manufacturers either stuck to selling in China, made inexpensive 3D printers, made copies of Western printers, or did some combination of all of the above....

Designing and Metal 3D Printing a Dental Implant

Les Kalman is Assistant Professor of Restorative Dentistry and Academic Lead for Continuing Dental Education at Western University’s Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry. He will be participating in Additive...

3D Printing Webinar and Event Roundup: January 23, 2022

We’ve got plenty of webinars and events to tell you about in this week’s roundup: NAMIC and CASTOR are talking 3D printed parts identification, Carbon has a major announcement, HP...


Shop

View our broad assortment of in house and third party products.