In pervious articles, we’ve discussed the benefits that 3D printing brings to tools for injection molding, die casting and forging. The technology also has its place in complementing or supplanting soft tooling, also referred to as rubber molding, silicone molding, room-temperature vulcanized (RTV) molding, or urethane casting.
Unlike hard tooling, made up of an aluminum or steel mold, soft tooling is comprised of silicone, urethane or other flexible materials and is used to produce parts with material properties that are more akin to a final injection molded material. This process is sometimes called RTV molding due to the fact that it can be performed at room temperature, unlike injection molding, which requires melting plastic pellets. Soft molds are usually manually injected with a given material through a gravity-fed tube.
Rubber molding is often used as a bridge between the prototyping phase and injection molded parts, providing material properties that are more akin to the final injection molded material but at a lower cost than hard tooling that will be used for end production. Moreover, it can be used to produce limited runs of final parts while hard tooling is being made. While soft tooling is typically more economical for smaller batch sizes, it can’t survive as many shots as a metal mold. Soft tooling may be utilized in any of the following circumstances:
- Properties of the final production material must be evaluated
- Quantity exceeds economical prototyping capacity
- A trial batch is necessary before production
- The design is not ready for production tooling
- Only small production batches (tens to hundreds) of items are required
3D printing is already used today in the fabrication of soft tools. A prototype may be made with stereolithography, digital light processing or some other high-resolution 3D printing technology, like material jetting (e.g., PolyJet from Stratasys, MultiJet Printing from 3D Systems, etc.), before a flexible silicone mold is made around the prototype. The right urethane is then selected to be injected into the mold to create a part.
Kevin Klotz, Sr. Project Engineer MGS Mfg. Group, for instance, told 3D Hubs that MGS uses 3D printing to produce molds directly, saying, “Sometimes it’s not so much the cost of a 3D printed tool insert verses a soft tool version, it is that we can’t produce the detail in the soft tool without, for instance, applying Electrical Discharge Machining (EDM) techniques. Somos PerFORM allows for the creation of detail that otherwise could not be made and to make it in less time.”
Recently, Israeli startup Nanofabrica has deployed its micro additive manufacturing technology to 3D print micro molds, dubbing the process “Direct Rapid Soft Tooling”. Nanofabrica’s Terra 250 AM system is an “ultra-high” resolution DLP machine that relies on semiconductor lithography to print layers as fine as 1 micron. The company, which recently raised $4 million in a financing round led by Microsoft’s M12 venture fund, was able to inject polypropylene, polyethylene and ABS into micro molds 3D printed with the Terra 250 AM system.
Molds lasted 20 shots at pressures of 400 bar at 230°C. Within the coming months, Nanofabrica is aiming to optimize the technology to create molds that can last 1,000 shots at temperatures of 350°C and pressures of 800 bar. So far, soft tooling that small was limited to research efforts, with a team from the Technical University of Denmark, printing micro mold inserts, as shown in the video below.
At the macroscale, now that polymer 3D printers are beginning to achieve the throughput and material properties possible with silicone molding, they are able to compete directly. In particular, companies like Carbon are working to develop materials that most closely resemble material properties used in injection molding, while AddiFab and Collider have learned how to combine injection molding with 3D printing in unique ways that allow for the use of existing injection molding plastics.
You May Also Like
3D Printing Webinar and Event Roundup: January 16, 2022
We’re back in business this week with plenty of webinars and events, both virtual and in-person, starting with the second edition of the all-female-speaker TIPE 3D Printing conference. There are...
Women in 3D Printing’s Posts Agenda for TIPE Conference and Virtual Career Fair
This January 18-20, Women in 3D Printing (Wi3DP) is back for the second time in a row with its TIPE 3D Printing Conference and Virtual Career Fair. Like its inaugural...
Women in 3D Printing Onboards New President
As the nonprofit celebrates seven years of supporting women in the additive manufacturing (AM) industry, Women in 3D Printing (Wi3DP) has taken on a new leader. Kristin Mulherin is taking...
3D Printing Trade Show Best Practices: Food and Food for Thought
This is the third installment of ideas, suggestions, and best practices for your 3D printing stand from an interested observer. We previously discussed booth location and how best to connect...
View our broad assortment of in house and third party products.