In ‘Effect of Ultrasonic Vibration on Interlayer Adhesion in Fused Filament Fabrication 3D Printed ABS,’ by Alireza Tofangchi, Pu Han, Julio Izquierdo, Adithya Iyengar and Keng Hsu, the authors examine the future of FFF (FDM, Material Extrusion) 3D printing, along with how different processes affect performance. They foresee greater potential for FFF printing as a serious tool in manufacturing, as materials, accuracy, finishing, and quality in parts begin to evolve.
With the use of 34.4 kHz ultrasonic vibrations during FFF 3D printing, the researchers found up to a 10 percent increase in ABS layer adhesion versus regular FFF processes.
“This increase in the interlayer adhesion strength is attributed to the increase in polymer reptation due to ultrasonic vibration-induced relaxation of the polymer chains from secondary interactions in the interface regions,” state the research team, hailing from the Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Louisville.
The team explains that there have been several different methods used for strengthening interlayer bonding; for example, adding more heat during or after printing has proven to be effective through elevating the ‘temperature dependent diffusivity.’ Enhancing the surface of filaments also proved to improve strength, along with both infrared and laser heating—added just before deposition of each layer. The researchers also noted that ‘reducing the radius of gyration of polymer chains could also result in similar improvement in inter-layer strength,’ effected through relaxing the polymer chains left in the 3D printed tracks.
Ultrasound vibrations permit both relaxation and diffusion of polymers, creating better interfacial adhesion—and possibly resulting in parts bearing isotropic mechanical properties. Testing occurred on a MakerGear M3 that the team customized for the inclusion of the vibrations. Vibrations were created with a 40 kHz-piezoelectric crystal-based bolt-clamped transducer with power rated at 25 W. This was connected to the heater block using a connecting rod and threaded fasteners.
“The use of the connecting rod allows for the coupling of vibrations generated by the transducer, and the reduction of heat transfer from the heater block into the transducer,” said the researchers. “With the hotend section mounted on the printhead assembly, the overall resonant frequency of the printhead was measured to be 34.4 kHz.”
“A frequency-adjustable ultrasonic signal generator was adjusted to the resonant frequency of the printhead and connected to the transducer to provide excitation signals that allowed the nozzle surface to vibrate at the measured frequency. This resonant frequency is determined by measuring the maximum vibration amplitude at the surface of the nozzle while sweeping the generator frequency. When excited at frequencies away from the measured resonance, the transducer output is instead dissipated in the entire transducer–connecting rod–hotend assembly as heat.”
Researchers measured peeling and energy of the inter-related bonds with the ASTM F88 Peel Test, a system well-known for evaluating adhesion between flexible bands that have been sealed. The test is relevant here as the subject matter is also flexible.
Results of the study show adhesion forces remaining consistent. When track width-to-nozzle diameter ration varies from .74 to 1.47, however, adhesion increases but then balances out at 1.2 and becomes lower at the larger ratios. Such reactions are caused by shear forces in the flow of the polymer traveling from the nozzle to flow horizontally. The wide increases, so do the flow rate and velocity of the polymer increases.
“This increase in flow velocity in turn increases the local shear stresses experienced by the polymer near the top and bottom surfaces of the track and causes an increased amount of disentanglement of polymer chains in those regions,” states the team. “This increase in chain alignment (or decrease in entanglement of polymer chains) can increase the diffusivity of the polymer in the orthogonal directions, which is conducive to an increase in interlayer adhesion due to increased reptation of the polymer across the interface.”
Diffusivity may be caused by polymer chain disentanglement which also adds to chain relaxation and then counteracts polymer reputation increases.
“The effects associated with the use of ultrasound vibrations are attributed to the ultrasound-induced increase in polymer chain relaxation from secondary interaction, and the resulting increase in reptation and entanglement from stretched states,” concluded the researchers.
What do you think of this news? Let us know your thoughts! Join the discussion of this and other 3D printing topics at 3DPrintBoard.com.