One thing that most 3D printer manufacturers like to brag about is printer speed; the speed of a printer actually varies a lot more than manufacturers tend to describe. More than one company has claimed to offer the “fastest printer in its class,” but those claims may only be true when it comes to certain printing applications. A printer may be able to print a large part at record speed, but that same printer might also be slower than most when printing especially small parts. Stratasys reseller CADD Edge discovered this during a recent speed test they performed on several of their printers.
The study, which CADD Edge has documented in a white paper entitled “3D Printer SPEED Comparison,” pitted several Stratasys printers, both high end and entry level, against each other for the purpose of creating a guide for customers wanting to get a realistic idea of the printer speeds they can expect when purchasing a particular model. The paper, which can be downloaded here, gives a detailed look at how print speeds compare on different applications. For example, which is the fastest printer for printing a single part, as opposed to the fastest for printing, say, twenty parts?
“Our speed comparison methodology was designed to give a rough idea of printer speed comparisons—not a comprehensive study—and so we deliberately chose a single part that would be printed on all the Stratasys printers using a standard material for each technology (FDM and PolyJet),” says Juan Carlos Gandiaga, application engineer for CADD Edge. “We did test printing for a single part build and then printing 5, 10 and 20 parts at once…the span of speed varies greatly across the line of printers we sell, but there’s a lot more to this story than the ‘fastest’ printer.”
For example, Gandiaga continues, one of their top-performing printers blew all of the other printers out of the water with speeds five to twenty times the speeds of entry level printers; however, that same printer was exceptionally slow when printing a very small part. This may be frustrating to consumers who want their printers to be fast no matter what they’re printing, but that’s a great reason for publishing a paper of this sort. Buying a 3D printer is a huge investment, with a dizzying array of factors to consider before purchasing, and so it’s helpful to have a guide that breaks features down into the best performers for specific applications.
Stratasys printers tested in the study included:
- uPrint SE Plus
- Fortus 250mc
- Fortus 380/450/900mc (results for these three printers were identical)
- Objet30 Prime
- Objet Eden260VS
- Objet260 Connex3
- Objet350 Connex3
- Objet500 Connex3
- Objet1000 Plus
In general, FDM printers were twice as fast as PolyJet printers when printing a single part. PolyJets, however, became much faster when asked to print multiple parts at one time. No single printer stood out above all others as being the overall fastest or best. It’s an interesting study, and one that should be tremendously helpful for those considering purchasing a 3D printer. Usually, when buying a 3D printer, the customer has some general idea of what types of things they’ll be using it for, so a study like this one should help interested buyers to narrow their choices down to the printer that meets their specific needs. Even if you’re not in the market for a new printer right now, it’s still worth taking a look at; the download is free and contains a lot of information that’s very helpful in terms of better understanding printer speed and the many factors that go into it. Discuss in the 3D Printer Speeds forum over at 3DPB.com.
You May Also Like
Cellink and Viscient’s Projects Will Aid Pandemic Research
The novel COVID-19 outbreak has altered the world at its core, transforming the foundation of most companies as economies begin to shut down to avoid a healthcare system collapse. In...
3D Printing and COVID-19, April 7, 2020 Update
Companies, organizations and individuals continue to attempt to lend support to the COVID-19 pandemic supply effort. We will be providing regular updates about these initiatives where necessary in an attempt...
Spanish Leitat1 Field Respirator Performs Initial Tests in ICU
Previously mentioned in our coverage of emergency medical supplies was the Leitat1 bag valve mask (BVM). The emergency respirator, which features 3D printed components and was developed by a consortium...
Safety Recomendations for 3D-Printed COVID-19 Medical Devices, Part One
One of the most important issues that we’ve repeatedly stressed in relation to the 3D printing community’s efforts to fulfill the need for medical supplies amid the COVID-19 pandemic is...
View our broad assortment of in house and third party products.